If all the sea were paper, and all the ships of card.. |
Maybe I should share with others some of the titles I have found useful and tell something of what particular books are good for.
I will make a few posts with reading tips.
You can find these titles second hand for little money. Personally, I never buy new books when I can get a good second hand copy cheap.
ABE BOOKS
BIBLIO
AMAZON USED LISTINGS etc.
In my opinion stay away from ebooks. They are awkward, require technology to read and do not smell of anything nor bear the evidence of others sharing your passion.OK if you collect Playboy this could be a plus...
Actually, my main bugbear with them is that they do not do figures or photos well and different books require different readers, etc. Bah, humbug !
My list helps you avoid buying a pig in a poke..or a glossy cover but in any case find the books online, read reviews and only then buy.
1) TOE-DIPPING BOOKS
Maybe you do not want to launch a trieres yet but you saw Ben Hur (Heston version) or heaven forbid, 300:Rise of an Empire, or a nice model and are thinking about what the topic involves and may offer in return for more study ?
One problem is that you may not know much of ancient writing which forms our historical basis for what we imagine galley warfare to have been like. I guarantee you will be infected with a virus that impels you to read every ancient author you can once you have been exposed to it.
The following books will provide a good introduction to the theme. Non are over-long and non are expensive.
..ancient sources.... |
SALAMIS by Barry Strauss, Arrow Books 2005
Lords of the Sea by John Hale, Viking 2009
It is possible to nit-pick on these titles but their accessibility and general dedication to promotion of the beautiful technology of ancient ships outweighs any detectable glitches. They also allow you to painlessly precis the ancient sources on auto-pilot. Maybe with enough detail so that you do not feel the need to buy any other books.
Love at first sight ? |
Building the Trireme by Frank Welsh, Constable 1988
The project from the viewpoint of its backer.
The Athenian Trireme by J.Morrison , J. Coates, N. Rankov, Cambridge 1988
The historical and technical background, progress of the project and conclusions.
If you buy one book about ancient ships, this is the one.
Another Morrison epic..for later.. |
John Morrison also authored a great introductory book on ancient ships. It is deceptively slim but this one volume can get you far.
THE SHIP, LONG SHIPS AND ROUND SHIPS,
J. Morrison, National Maritime Museum, HMSO 1980
ROMANS
Two titles by an author who takes his own photos and makes ship models! Very detailed and comprehensive material on the Roman side of things. Either of these two will set you up,,for a Bellum Civile.
Roman Warships by Michael Pitassi, Boydell Press 2011
The Roman Navy by Michael Pitassi , Seaforth Publishing 2012
OSPREY TITLES
Osprey has a handful of titles which also allow a rapid coverage of the topic. Some are better than others but the principal to remember is that they are starting points, often with a personal viewpoint, with nice piccies rather than the last or comprehensive word on each subject.
THE GOOD
Pylos and Sphakteria 425bc : Campaign 261 by William Shepherd
Salamis 480bc : Campaign 222 by William Shepherd
Syracuse 415-413bc : Campaign 195 by Nic Fields
THE UGLY / THE BAD
Just joking. None are truly bad. I just have a problem that some titles have better draughtsmanship and understanding of how a ship works than others when it comes to illustration of wooden ships.
Previous blogs on this subject are tagged as OSPREY
Actium 31BC Campaign 211 by Si Sheppard
ANCIENT WARSHIP
REPUBLICAN ROMAN WARSHIP
IMPERIAL ROMAN WARSHIP
ANCIENT GREEK WARSHIP
Go to Osprey to find them HERE
The BIG and Beautiful
Coffee table books on ancient warfare are less common these days but a handful exist that are now old but still good which you MUST get hold of. They are things of beauty and will entertain you for years. Actually my copies do not get onto any coffee table, they are safely on the shelf or being perused regularly...
Warfare in the Classical World John Warry, Salamander Books 1980
This book is unique in having fantastic drawings of several types of galley by Jeff Burns who has illustrated many military books for Osprey , too.
Also discussion of ships and naval tactics. And much, much more!
Greece and Rome at War by Peter Connolly, Macdonald 1981
Only a few appearances of warships. But surely you have this already !? Can be got for a son gin paperback edition. Short references and illustrations re. Salamis and the corvus.
Warfare in the Ancient World, Ed. Hackett, Illustrated by Connolly, Sidgwick and Jackson 1989
Short references and illustrations re. Salamis and the corvus.
Lionel Casson
Along with
from Morrison and Coates, Lionel Casson has
produced fantastic writing on ancient ships and seafaring. He began the
conjoining of technical archaeological research and ancient sources to
flesh-out our understanding of ancient maritime activities
Ships and Seafaring in Ancient Times by Lionel Casson, British Museum Press 1994
The Ancient Mariners by Lionel Casson, Princeston University Press 1991
I make no secret that I think this subject offers a rich variety of material ranging from ancient history and archaeology to military and commercial history, social history and development, ancient technology and the evolution of wooden ships. The smell of tar and salt water, the splash of oars and the rustle of pages, the thud of a book-sized parcel landing in the postbox and the discovery that you suddenly understand some otherwise enigmatic passages someone wrote more than two thousand years ago. All this and card model ships too!
May I ask what your view is of Rome versus Carthage: The War at Sea, by Steinby? You mentioned in passing in another post, but without giving it any recommendation. Is it worthwhile adding it to the list?
ReplyDeleteI have a piece I am putting together dealin gwith Pen and Sword's galley books together. In the meantime,, despite her book being sold as the first treatment of the Republican navy in 50 years , I think it is a totally conservative regurgitation of ancient sources with her only thesis being 'Polybius was oversimplifying when he said Rome was not a sea-power before the First Punic War'. But she offers no new evidence or perspectives. Her knowledge of galley warfare seems basic. My opinion.
ReplyDelete