Naval Warfare with Ancient Galleys : Card model ships, wargame rules and the background for their development : All original material copyright
Friday 1 May 2020
Tuesday 28 April 2020
SALAMIS . What scale for a refight?
Considering how to best do a refight of Salamis in the year the Greeks have chosen to celebrate as the 2500th anniversary I intend to to a refight with 1 model for 1 ship.
A basic question is what scale? 'Normal' waterline models come in at 1200th or 600th scale withthe diminutive 3600th scale also available. I decided to resist the temptation to use 1/72 Academy, Atlantic or Zvezda ships....
The area of the battlefield is an important consideration because your wife will probably resist any intention to knock the living room and dining room into one because of something which happened so long ago. (Was it Tony Bath who had to reinforce his ceiling because he put an enormous sand-table in the loft? Ed.)
Deciding what scale to fight the battle I drew up a table of values for comparison between the scales.
The total number of ships engaged can range from 600 to 1800 depending on what you want to recreate. In any event it means 500 or so models.
The 'bottom line' is where considerations of space and cost led me. Covid19 has put the kaibosh on any use of the local hall. So a smaller scale and cheaper figures are needed.
I have made some trials with 1200 and 1000 scale models mainly to use a scale where the ships are individual models rather than counters. I like Outpost 1/3600 See HERE and in header photo - but I will try to do the project in as large a scale as possible.
Trying out some 1/1200 rules for unit-scale gaming...
With beginnings of 1/1200 models in high density polystyrene
1/1000 model prototypes under way.
1/1000 scale models set for moulding - to be cast in resin.
I have a reserve option, to cast the ships using glue-gun glue but I will see how good they look in resin first and calculate the price.
A basic question is what scale? 'Normal' waterline models come in at 1200th or 600th scale withthe diminutive 3600th scale also available. I decided to resist the temptation to use 1/72 Academy, Atlantic or Zvezda ships....
The area of the battlefield is an important consideration because your wife will probably resist any intention to knock the living room and dining room into one because of something which happened so long ago. (Was it Tony Bath who had to reinforce his ceiling because he put an enormous sand-table in the loft? Ed.)
Your dining room/gaming table/garage floor is here.. |
Deciding what scale to fight the battle I drew up a table of values for comparison between the scales.
The total number of ships engaged can range from 600 to 1800 depending on what you want to recreate. In any event it means 500 or so models.
The 'bottom line' is where considerations of space and cost led me. Covid19 has put the kaibosh on any use of the local hall. So a smaller scale and cheaper figures are needed.
I have made some trials with 1200 and 1000 scale models mainly to use a scale where the ships are individual models rather than counters. I like Outpost 1/3600 See HERE and in header photo - but I will try to do the project in as large a scale as possible.
Trying out some 1/1200 rules for unit-scale gaming...
With beginnings of 1/1200 models in high density polystyrene
1/1000 model prototypes under way.
Fiddly bits |
Not bad when assembled. Greeks on left, Barbarians with depth charges ready for Greek sponge fishermen attacks |
1/1000 scale models set for moulding - to be cast in resin.
I have a reserve option, to cast the ships using glue-gun glue but I will see how good they look in resin first and calculate the price.
Monday 27 April 2020
CARTHGINIAN HELMET FROM EGADI
I found another photo of this helmet, now cleaned.
I was hoping the gunge might be hiding something exotic but it would appear this is a pilos type helmet. Though the brim is quite wide and there may be some details we cannot see and the magazine article does not mention.
The Roman poet Silius ( yes , it's true! he was a relative of Biggus maybe ? Ed.) Italicus tells us that a Carthaginian could wear a masked helmet with cheek pieces in his epic poem Punica.
The Roman champion Asilus meets the Carthaginian Berytas in battle..
The pilos helmets derived from a heavy felt cap - the pilos/pileus - which was worn as head protection in battle also - being light but capable of stopping all but the most direct blows. In the Sfakteria campaign the Spartans were not best pleased that arrows pierced their piloi easily.
There is a chance another of these brimmed styles is represented....
The brim is quite broad and flared like this luxury example.
Anyway, before I disappear down the rabbit hole that is helmet typology ..I did find that some of these deceptively simple helmets can have cheek guards and neck-guard attached.
This fine example resides in Australia!
This was probably made in southern Italy in the fourth century BC . Close to our date and place..
(Robinson, E. G. D. 1995. "South Italian Bronze Armour." In Classical Art in the Nicholson Museum, Sydney, edited by Cambitoglou, A. and Robinson, E. G. D., 145-66. Mainz)
Anyway what might come up from the seabed in the next few years ?????
Archaeologica Viva XXXV N.177 |
The Roman poet Silius ( yes , it's true! he was a relative of Biggus maybe ? Ed.) Italicus tells us that a Carthaginian could wear a masked helmet with cheek pieces in his epic poem Punica.
The Roman champion Asilus meets the Carthaginian Berytas in battle..
...while fighting in
the centre of the fray, he came upon
Beryas, who had been sent by the Carthaginians to
make a treaty with the king of Syracuse and was
fighting side by side with the Syracusans ; but his
face was concealed by the brazen helmet that he
wore. Asilus attacked him with the steel, and,
as he tottered feebly backwards, hurled him to
the ground. Then, when he heard his conqueror's
voice, the poor wretch, recalling his life as it were
from Hades in fear and trembling, tore from his chin
the straps that bound his useless helmet, and asked
for mercy at the same time. He was about to say
more, when the Tuscan, startled by the sudden sight
of that familiar face, withdrew his sword and thus
addressed his antagonist, ere he could speak, with
sighs and tears : " Sue not, I pray, to me for hfe
with doubts and entreaties. For me it is right to
save my enemy. The noble warrior is he, whose first
and last thought is to keep faith even in time of war.
You began it and saved me from death before I saved
you. I should deserve the troubles I have met, and
should deserve to meet again with worse troubles, if
my right hand failed to clear a path for you through
fire and sword." With these words he raised Beryas
willingly from the ground and granted a life
Beryas, who had been sent by the Carthaginians to
make a treaty with the king of Syracuse and was
fighting side by side with the Syracusans ; but his
face was concealed by the brazen helmet that he
wore. Asilus attacked him with the steel, and,
as he tottered feebly backwards, hurled him to
the ground. Then, when he heard his conqueror's
voice, the poor wretch, recalling his life as it were
from Hades in fear and trembling, tore from his chin
the straps that bound his useless helmet, and asked
for mercy at the same time. He was about to say
more, when the Tuscan, startled by the sudden sight
of that familiar face, withdrew his sword and thus
addressed his antagonist, ere he could speak, with
sighs and tears : " Sue not, I pray, to me for hfe
with doubts and entreaties. For me it is right to
save my enemy. The noble warrior is he, whose first
and last thought is to keep faith even in time of war.
You began it and saved me from death before I saved
you. I should deserve the troubles I have met, and
should deserve to meet again with worse troubles, if
my right hand failed to clear a path for you through
fire and sword." With these words he raised Beryas
willingly from the ground and granted a life
in exchange for the life he had
received.
Well we must make do with the only Carthaginian helmet found on a maritime battle site....
The pilos helmets derived from a heavy felt cap - the pilos/pileus - which was worn as head protection in battle also - being light but capable of stopping all but the most direct blows. In the Sfakteria campaign the Spartans were not best pleased that arrows pierced their piloi easily.
HARDWEAR warrior from Pella , northern Greece 300BC (Livius.org) |
SOFTWEAR : Louvre pot - Bill or Ben ? |
There is a chance another of these brimmed styles is represented....
sketches from HERE |
random on ewb---- |
This fine example resides in Australia!
Nicholson Museum Helmet: |
(Robinson, E. G. D. 1995. "South Italian Bronze Armour." In Classical Art in the Nicholson Museum, Sydney, edited by Cambitoglou, A. and Robinson, E. G. D., 145-66. Mainz)
Anyway what might come up from the seabed in the next few years ?????
Look at it--thousands of shields helmets, armour, spears, daggers, belts... if just 1% survives! |
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)